The first thing that caught our eye about Complete Internet Hosting was a great answer to my biggest complaint about hosting providers. Most hosting providers will suck you in with a relatively aggressive starting price, but when it comes time to renew, the renewal price can be two or three times the original price. I've even found one company that renews at more than six times the original price.
Hosting specifically tailored to your needs and requirements, A Small Orange is the perfect solution for your personal website. They follow one single rule which makes sure you pay only for the resources that you need and nothing more. While they are on the raise, ASO is keeping things very personal. Hence they might be one of the best options for you from the list. Notice that A Small Orange is not the cheapest option but all for a good reason. Either you go with the cheapest shared plan or WordPress exclusive, you will pay at around $5 per month.
Great article, Paul! Definitely one of the best reads on web hosting that I've seen. I was pleasantly surprised to see Hostinger taking the first spot. In my opinion, they fully deserve all the praise that they get. Your example with the customer support test proves that point perfectly. No hidden tricks, no downtime, no long support waits. I'm really glad I decided to give them a shot a while ago. Cheers.